As you know Sader 1970, I grew up in Smithtown and attended high school at the current location of St. Anthony's and traveled to St. John the Baptist on several occasions for various athletic contests. Travel-wise it's really 6 of one half-dozen of the other.
South Huntington is probably closer by a couple of miles, but from Smithtown, the primarily east west travel to St. A's vs. more north south travel to West Islip and SJ the B means the extra traffic likely off-sets the shorter distance to get to South Huntington.
Still, she should have gone to St. Anthony's, a far superior school.
What do I know? Like Holy Cross, I probably wouldn't be admitted to either Holy Cross or St. Anthony's. But both places don't mind hitting me up for money each year.
P.S. Just got this video. A new thing that St. A's sends to alums. This principal, Brother David, is new. This is the 4th or 5th that I've seen. I challenge you all to watch it and dare you to tell me you didn't smile at his enthusiasm:
Just stumbled across this recent offer from last month: Bronagh Power-Cassidy 5'11" G/F from Ireland doing a prep year at Marianapolis Prep. Apparently also received one from Merrimack. Her first 2 offers. Played on the Irish U18 & 19 teams